Monthly Archives: March 2022

A bit of education (part two)

(continued from last week)

I won’t march you through all the other episodes and disappointments elementary school brought. I will say that I had always been a believer in public schools and the importance of the company of peers, so we went on, year after year, trying to see a better outcome. Yet by fifth grade I had to admit the circumstances of this form of learning had come perilously close to closing down our kid’s curiosity and wish to learn. Perilously close also, to losing me my patience, my sympathy with over-burdened teachers facing bulging classrooms and too many conflicting directives.

I had concerns also with the bullying environment at the school, where most bullying passed under the radar.  Some teachers stepped up to the responsibility of being in loco parentis, but I remember one nice young teacher explaining earnestly that he wasn’t comfortable imposing his personal ethics on other people’s children. That declaration left me speechless. As the adult in the room, who would share his or her ethics if he, the adult, refused? Children don’t wait to ask their parents at home before they learn what works on the grounds of the school.

In response I went back to the distance learning program, Calvert, that my family had used when in Nigeria and no school available within commuting distance. I called Calvert, we went through the standardized test required for admission, and discovered that compared to national standards, the kid was over three years behind in mathematics, and one and a half years ahead in reading and writing skills.

Thus,  we engaged in part-time home-school using the Calvert School materials.  Part-time because as an only child I figured she still needed the company of other children. Further, most school districts allow this if the child attends the standard classroom a certain number of hours each day.

I kept thinking, asking myself– we are by ancient inheritance hunter-gatherers. Is that an inheritance we might tap?

I believe engaging with Calvert helped. But it wasn’t enough. We finally turned away from the local public schools to finding a middle school that allowed adventures, in fact required them, and that was a turning point for us all. I will never claim it was easy, but it was definitely wonderful. Literally, full of wonder. A private school, worth every penny because it opened back up the idea of joy in learning. What our kid got was the company of engaged caring adults on her hero’s journey to become an independent world-oriented human being.

So I asked the question above about using our inheritance, and maybe I answered part of it, that human engagement is necessary to the person we want to become. Wherever we find it– behind the school sneaking some vaping time with friends, or bicycling up a mountain road that feels impossible, with your aunt ahead looking like she doesn’t know what it is to sweat, and your sandwich toasting in your backpack.

We learn, and one of the things we must learn if we are to keep on learning and gaining skills, is that at the end of the day it doesn’t matter if the book is at your reading level if you can understand what it says. We learn that learning is for ourselves, not so we can check a box and be done with it.  And what are the ‘its’ that matter at the end? Only we define them. Especially when we do things that are not in our easy reach, not in our wheelhouse, not at our reading level.

I know a woman who took third year college French language without any preparation, not even a high school course. At midterm she had a hard-won ‘D’, and after that her grade scraped upwards until her professor called her into the office.

            “I don’t know what’s been wrong with you,” he said, not knowing the paucity of her background, and you can bet she didn’t let out a squeak lest he pitch her out on her ear, “but your improvement is admirable. Let’s say I throw out all your previous grades and you can have whatever grade you get on my final.”

            Yes, she aced it.

            She had a place in the College of Creative Studies at the University of California, Santa Barbara, some decades ago. A school with the cap off, literally, in terms of credit limits. A graduate school for undergraduates, where it’s likely to have your original research published or presented in a professional journal before you graduate. It might sound narrow, but it’s powered by a kind of thinking and wanting that breaks boxes.  For example, CCS had a student who graduated having fulfilled all the requirements for three disparate majors. He finished in four years like all the others, though by his own admission–“It was a little crazy. I guess I should have taken another quarter.”

            What’s the common thread to find an education? Be hungry for what interests you. Master the skills you will need to possess it all. Feed the courage that faces the chance to fail, a will to try the difficult. Seek opportunity and hard sweaty work. Find people who care to help you. No boxes. Just like real life.

            Now I need to catch up….

2 Comments

Filed under blog, education, homework, school,

A bit of education (part one)

I know I have written on this subject before, but I am going to say a bit more, perhaps add more specifics, so I think it’s worth the exercise, or at least I hope so.

My supposedly mainstream child barely fit into school. Think of a box of expectations, then think of cutting pieces off, bending bits to stuff them in. She arrived at the kindergarten door asking “Can you teach me how internal combustion engines work?” A totally obnoxious question, I know, and I promise you, that having been a teacher myself, I did not coach her to say that.

Instead, the teachers taught her to color inside the lines of some really poorly drawn pictures with huge coarse areas to cover. The idea was to have even color spread all over every section. As an artist I can give an opinion here that these designs were not going to be better for even color. To assume a kid doesn’t care what a product looks like is a huge mistake. To bestow a bad grade on the project when the kid tries to re-draw the objects is not encouraging of better effort. Whatever better may be.

This classroom introduced the kid to the stop watch. The notion was to teach the kids numbers, and how to do simple addition and subtraction equations, fifty of them, in under sixty seconds. Not once a day, but repeatedly. Then they sent home a sheaf of these as assignments, mixed in with more coloring assignments to sweeten the task with more tasks. Tedium rarely helps any learning process that I have witnessed.

The classroom also taught the alphabet and phonics. Phonics are a super construct that works brilliantly, I think, for most kids. But there are forms of dyslexia that make phonics impossible. Our kid turned out to have one of these, she was willing, but unable. Did they have an alternative method? No, the school said she was a poor student, suggested better discipline, less TV (which she didn’t watch anyway,) and more homework, so her aunt and I taught her reading at home, and the kid did what I had done in my own young years– memorized the spellings.

When she received for the school the highest score in her second-grade standardized test for spelling, the front office at the school accused her of cheating. Fortunately this made her second-grade teacher laugh instead of following up on the scandal, so all was well, but I felt the sting of being beholden to one person’s opinion to get us out of trouble. After all, we expected our kid to go quite a few grades further than second grade, so why cheat? How would you cheat? What good would it have done her?

Beginning in early second grade I ran a homework group for a disparate group of six kids (actually the number varied up to eight) from the same grade, ranging from academic overachievers to learning-disabled and ESL. It helped socialize all of us, but this also let me see a range of experience with struggles and successes.

At the end of our days in elementary school, I felt that the school system failed nearly all the children around my table, no matter their gifts, by making work punishment instead of joy. Everything became about rushing to check a box. Hurrying to get it over with.

For example, reading…starting in second grade we had to report weekly on reading at home. Trying to quantify every book read into a daily number count of pages — that too, became a penalty rather than a pleasure. For a kid who read several books a night but was so literal about honesty she had to record every page for this report, it felt punitive. Some of the other kids around my table simply made up page counts and titles. The teachers were too over-burdened to check. I could look disappointed at them and try to gently object when the kids confessed and giggled about it, but I don’t think that changed what they did.

 We as a society apparently don’t understand learning well. We don’t know how to institutionalize and mass-produce the experience without damaging it.

I think the one thing that got our group through with good memories was hours of reading aloud to that table of kids after school (even though some could read far faster than ever a human can voice.) Main stream children?  I felt so often we were preparing them for obedience, not for thinking, not analyzing, but box checking, and what does that suggest? But reading aloud, especially, reading far above the supposedly appropriate reading level for each, stretches minds and fills them with questions. And it shows that we are all here together and we care.

We read Berton Rouche’s Annals of Epidemiology, and The Fellowship of the Ring, by Tolkien. Random pieces from adult history books, and the records of the Supreme Court, to give light to laws. We talked about ideas and batted questions back and forth. How a heart works, why does manure make plants grow, what’s a lute, where do you find cassava and is it toxic? We looked at maps and the magazine Science News. When 9/11 brought them home to me from school early, all worried puzzled and tense, we talked about world religions and their impact on politics and history, and the power geography had upon both. We went to look at the wall map because only one kid knew where Afghanistan was located. In what we read, in what we discussed, we ran together before we could walk.

I also baked a lot of cookies, hot rolls, and cakes, because learning tastes sweeter when you’re eating a treat. All the milk or water they could drink, and home-made food, with breaks to run around the garden or play at sword fighting with wooden swords. I told them that was fine, but they mustn’t do any damage that required a doctor. They listened, though I probably watched them a lot more closely than they knew. And since I made the swords, I knew the wood was light and the swords were blunt.

(to be continued)

1 Comment

Filed under blog, education, experiences, family history, homework, school,

I want peace in the world

Cooking Without Limits

It has been a few crazy days in my area. We are close to the border of Ukraine and since the war started we have had refugees coming our way. Some of them are staying for good, some until the war is over and some just go to other countries.

I did not have time to post anything about food or photography. I will try to post it when I have time. I am a volunteer together with my friends for an ONG that helps the person in need. These days we are helping lots of refugees to run from the war, start a new life, or survive the new world.

So, please forgive the lack of recipes or tips about food photography.

If you want to donate you can find the details here:

Asociația Donează Gura Humorului

CONT LEI RO85BTRLRONCRT0508224001

CONT EURO RO35BTRLEURCRT0508224001

PayPal: doneazagh21@gmail.com

Thank you for your…

View original post 1 more word

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized