I find that my dearest of the Jane Austen novels remains Persuasion. Delicate and insightful, biting and awfully funny in a restrained way startling you with unexpected drama that arises naturally out of the characters and their flaws and strengths. But thinking of the beginning I find myself considering how it fits, as so often Austen does, into a commentary most current and urgent.


Anne Elliot the daughter, the Elliot family’s man of business and the nosy neighbor sit down with the man “of means” Sir Elliot, who needs for the first time in his life to live within those means.  But it’s not simply that he needs to live a reformed life that fits his assets – he needs to live well below his old style, such that he can repay the debts he has incurred. He must retrench.


This is a reflection we might take for ourselves. We need to deal with retrenching in terms of our lives and our planet.  We have so far overspent we need to seriously re-budget our lifestyles and expectations – well below what we now take as expected. This may be as unwelcome a thought to us as retrenching was to Sir Elliot, but if we wish to have our next two or perhaps more generations experience reasonable comfort, we must consider and act upon this unwelcome assessment.


I live in a small city so I take the bus instead of driving. Our family tries hard to do no more than one shopping run a week, to organize our needs so we aren’t dashing off for missing components of dinner or the screws to hang my next show of paintings. We grow a part of our food, probably not enough, and make efforts to conserve on our utilities and water. Yet my profile, trimmed back though it is, still would require many earths for everyone to live as I do. As I keep reminding myself… we only have one.



Filed under Uncategorized

4 responses to “Persuasion

  1. Vy Chazen

    I love Persuasion. You said it best with the word restrained. I often wonder what the Elliots would have been like if Anne’s mother was still alive. Would Sir Elliot and Elizabeth have been any different?

    • I think Lady Russell suggested Anne was like her mother in temperment. I wonder if Anne’s mother had as much influence over Sir Walter as Lady Russell seemed to think? Sir Elliot always heard what he wanted to hear, like most of us! We could hope Elizabeth would have been more balanced under the influence of both parents, but with her father’s constant example, it’s quite a question. Sometimes it seems that vanity calls to vanity.

      • Vy Chazen

        I’m not sure if you saw the 1971 version of Persuasion, but they portrayed Sir Elliot as a silly man instead of a vulgar one like the 2007(?) one. Also, I recommend David M. Shapard’s annotated Persuasion. It has great notes in it.

  2. I only saw the Amanda Root and Ciaran Hinds version, I think it may have been late 1990’s — many flaws and deviations but I did like Amanda Root as Anne and Ciaran Hinds is fun to watch. I’ve generally avoided many of the Austen-based movies, and would be curious which you have found the most faithful to her spirit? (I did see the BBC many-episode version of Pride and Prejudice which I confess gave me many fine moments!)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s